Is this the end? How do we feel?

It has been a few weeks since we received the Government’s decision on the third application to ‘deregulate’ (close) farm terrace. People keep offering their condolences and asking is this is the end of the line? Honestly I don’t know. How do we feel? We know the decision is morally wrong. We are thankful that our fantastic legal team have agreed to look through this latest document to see if it is legally wrong and we are comforted by the support of local residents and supporters far and wide.

And we have been here three times before.

The first time back in May 2013 was the worst. We were sure that the government would back us up. Andy our chairman and others spent weeks completing our submission, which still stands as a robust document, so when the Watford Observer called me for a quote about the fact ‘we had lost’ – it was the first I had heard and I was shaking with shock. I met my neighbours who also have a plot there and we cried in the street. Luckily in July 2013 we got legal support funded through crowd funding and challenged that the decision had been incorrectly made. In August 2013 the Secretary Of State acknowledged his error in the decision and through a Judicial review formally quashed the deregulation decision. But in September 2013 Watford Borough Council put in a 2nd submission to close the site.

In December 2013 the SOS agreed a second deregulation whilst stating exceptional circumstances for the first time as the statutory criteria to close had not been fully met. I heard about this when a friend called me. This time I was not so surprised but the exceptional circumstances threw me. It still does. On July 25th 2014 We took the government and the council to the Royal courts of justice for a second Judicial review and on October 31st 2014 we found out that we had won!

In January 2015 Watford Borough Council put in their third submission to close the allotments. They believed that it was simply a matter of updating the information that was referred to by the judge and that the decision would be made quickly. The update from the Council that ran to 44 pages and 43 appendices.

We were made to wait 15 months.

On the 26th May 2016, this year, I was sat on the park having a picnic after school with my family when the same friend called to tell me the news that the government had agreed a third time to deregulate. My phone didn’t stop ringing that afternoon. It was mainly the press but also supporters trying to make sense of the legal jargon.

I felt numb. I still do. As I have explained we have been here before but each time you hope that this time ‘they’ will see sense. That this time David will beat Goliath.

We know that there will be no hospital buildings built on the Farm Terrace land. We know that all the plots will be bulldozed over to build flats and car parks. We know that this unique green lung that has been with us since the 1890’s and surrounded by buildings and traffic, once lost will be gone forever. We are not unique, many allotments are being ‘sold’ to developers but we are the most high profile case.

One day I am convinced that school children will study our case. The question I ask myself is whether they will study it because finally we won or will they study it because we lost and it marked the end of allotment gardens?

Don’t worry. We will fight on!

The Farm Terrace Story

Artichokes with flats behind!

The Farm Terrace Story

Farm Terrace lies behind Watford Football Club’s football ground in the densely populated area of west Watford made up of mainly terrace housing with small gardens. The allotments date back to 1896 and were formally an old sewage farm, the soil is amazing.

It currently covers 2.63 hectares or 128 plots. Originally it was at least 3 times this size.

In May 2012 we received a letter from Watford Borough Council stating that the allotments could be needed as part of the Health Campus development, which was to include possible hospital buildings, houses, flats (now 750 in total) and ironically green space.

At the same time, the Council also closed our waiting list and have since 2012 not allowed new tenants on Farm Terrace.

In December 2012 – Watford Council decided they wanted the entire allotment site to develop on as part of the ‘Health Campus’ scheme.

It was at this time that I started a social media campaign, using Face book and twitter.  My first ever tweet said “Help the council wants to build flats on our beloved allotments’

The response was phenomenal with so much support from so many people.

We were not against the hospital re-development but we soon realised that the hospital had no funding or firm plans for any expansion.

The allotment site only takes up roughly 20% of the total area of the Health Campus scheme but we were happy to compromise and thought that we would make a wonderful integral part of the garden-less estate and an opportunity for use by the hospital which stands to the side of us.

But the council would not listen to us and the consultation process was basically just a box ticking exercise.

In January 2013 – We formed a Community Association whilst Watford Borough Council wrote to the Government formally requesting the closure of the site.

Legally the council had to relocate us they offered us a horse grazing pasture over 2 miles away!

In February 2013 – We lodged a Community asset request with Watford Council

Unsurprisingly in April 2013 Watford Council denied the Community asset request. Significantly the council conceded that in all respects the application was sound, and that the only reason to deny the application was because the council had resolved to build on the site.

In May 2013 the then secretary of state Eric pickles agreed the deregulation, we were as you can imagine heartbroken.

We put in a FOI request and found out that this had indeed happened to many others, and in fact as I said before that between 2007-2013 there had been 199 applications to deregulate sites, 128 were approved  only  4 were declined (67 were withdrawn/undecided or invalid)

Basically that the government had agreed 80% of deregulations!

But in July 2013 – We got legal support with the prestigious ‘Deighton Pierce and Glynn’ legal practice, and we raised money through crowd funding so we challenged that the decision had been incorrectly made.

In August 2013 – The SOS acknowledges an error in its decision and a Judicial Review was lodged to formally quash the deregulation decision

But in September 2013 – Council put in 2nd submission to close site

December 2013 – SOS agrees second deregulation whilst stating exceptional circumstances for the first time as the statutory criteria to close had not been fully met

Coincidentally, in January 2014   – The SOS releases new allotment guidance “clarifying” the criteria that needed to be met for applications to close allotments whilst allowing an “exceptional circumstances” clause to be considered if the criteria to close have not been fully met.

In July 2014 we took our case to the Royal Courts of Justice in Westminster and over 100 allotment holders and supporters  put on what was called ‘The most colourful and ‘peasful’ protest the Royal courts of Justice had ever seen!’

While we were waiting for the decision the council wrote to plot holders offering a generous compensation of up to £1,000, way above the statutory minimum required, to vacate our plots

On October 31st 2014 we found out that we had won the judicial review! You can imagine the party!

But again In January 2015 Watford Borough Council put in their third submission to take the land stating that all that was needed this time was a minor update to previous submissions. However this ‘update’ ran to 45 pages and 43 appendices.

In April of this year the Department of Communities and Local Government informed us that the decision would not be made until after the General election when the new Government was in place.

We are still awaiting a decision from the new secretary of state Greg Clark.

I honestly don’t know what will happen to Farm Terrace. But I can tell you that we won’t stop fighting!

Does Watford need an elected Mayor?

Mr Pickles

For those of you who have missed out on the election news in Watford, it was good news for Farm Terrace.

The Conservative MP Richard Harrington (who supports deregulation of the Allotments) won the seat but it is still good news for Farm Terrace, let me explain why –

Our elected Mayor, Dorothy Thornhill who has been the driving force behind the 3 submissions to deregulate the allotments only achieved third place in the election despite stating that she was the only person who could beat Richard Harrington. Matt Turmaine from Labour who supports the retention of the Allotments came a reasonable second with 14,606 votes with Richard Harrington achieving 24,400+ votes. I know myself that many people used their votes tactically as many people were scared that Dorothy would get in so voted for Richard to stop her becoming MP.

Also at the same time a number of local council seats were up for election with the Lib Dems (Dorothy’s party) losing a number of seats to both Labour and the Conservatives. This left the council more evenly balanced politically than it has been for many years (Lib Dems 19 seats – including the elected Mayor), Labour 13 & Conservatives 5).

http://www.watfordobserver.co.uk/news/12940443._Lib_Dem_s_13_year_grip_on_Watford_Council_is_now_set_to_end__say_opposition_after_crushing_election_night/?ref=mr&lp=7

Next year there are more local council elections (as the town’s boundary’s are changing) and there will be another round of local elections meaning that the Lib Dem seats which were ‘safe’ may not be any more…

Taking into account that even if we lose this 3rd attempt at deregulation (now that the new Conservative government has been formed) we potentially still have at least 2 more growing seasons taking us to Autumn 2016 and by this point the whole of Watford Council could look different by then, which brings me on to my next point…

Do we really need an ‘elected mayor’ in Watford? Please see the following thread from the comments section of the Watford Observer’s story (http://www.watfordobserver.co.uk/news/12939065.Richard_Harrington_storms_to_Watford_victory/?ref=mr&lp=13 ) and take particular note of the way ‘Wacko Jacko’ responds (he is well known to be Councillor Iain Sharpe, the partner of Dorothy Thornhill!)

ME:

‘Relieved that Dorothy did SO badly. There was a lot of tactical voting going on to keep her out because of the Farm Terrace Case and many other fiascos. We now have to look at how to get her out of her Mayoral role…’

WACKO JACKO:

‘Sorry I’ve been out of communication over the past few weeks, I’ve had an election to fight.

Sarah, what you are forgetting is that Harrington is in complete agreement with Dorothy on the subject of the Health Campus, only he is in a much more powerful position than DT to deliver it.

The huge vote in his favour should be interpreted as a vote in support of the Health Campus and a mandate to get on and deliver it. Also please note that Dorothy has three more years to run as Mayor, by which time the project will be in full delivery mode and your allotments will have been turned into much needed homes.

I like to quote figures, so here is a new one to ponder, Watford now has over 200 families registered as homeless and in temporary accommodation at great cost to us the taxpayers, whereas the allotment land which could go a long way to solving that problem benefits only around 20 families who could easily move to one of Watford’s allotment sites with vacant plots,

As I’ve said before your dog in the manger campaign, supported by Labour, is a disgrace, a waste of our money and is against the interests of the many poor families who deserve a proper home in Watford. In a word it is simply selfish.’

 ME:

‘Oh Mr Sharpe/ Mr Dorothy Thornhill, I imagine you have been VERY busy picking up the pieces left after the people of Watford voted massively against your wife! Perhaps now it is time you both faced the truth that no one in Watford trusts her anymore and they would even vote for a ‘Conservative’ who lives in North Watford – just to make completely sure that she doesn’t enter into Westminster and muck even more things up! Now as you like facts so much..

Your wife gets paid (in these economically difficult times) £65,000 +Pension, +allowance, + add ons and she thought so little of this role that

  1. A) She went for MP, B) She thought it was perfectly acceptable to do both and be a part time Mayor (for the full wage obviously) and also take the wage and responsibilities of a full time MP (Had she won).

Now I for one believe that the role of elected Mayor in Watford, has been proven by your wife, to be completely unnecessary and complete and utter waste of Tax payers money who paid £220,000 for the Mayor’s office – last year!!

What a shameful waste of money. This has to stop! Nobody else has an ‘elected mayor’- why should we? Particularly one who no one has any confidence in?’

So the question I have for all you Watford residents is who agrees with me? Is it time for a change?

Does Watford need an elected Mayor?